January 21, 2011

Bagster - Review


An inevitable byproduct of tinkering around on your house is something known in English as 'trash.' Scraps of sheet rock, cut-offs, demo'd materials, etc. For the big jobs, you go and get a dumpster, for the small ones, you cut everything up into small pieces and use contractor bags. But what about those mid-sized projects like a big set of built-ins or relocating a wall? The answer used to be: "find a friend with a pickup truck who lives in a town with a lax dump policy," but now, the answer may very well be, 'get a Bagster." Waste Management, who runs the Bagster program, was nice enough to let us fill one up for a review and here's what we found...


First off, we have to say that in addition to the Bagster (and a no-charge pickup), Waste Management sent us a $500 gift card in order to cover expenses so that we could fill up the Bagster. So we'll take a moment to share our feelings on the gift card. Our initial thought at this offering was, "whoa, bribe!" But then we started thinking about it and it began to make sense. A Bagster can hold a lot of trash (3 cubic yards) and to get that kind of debris in a reasonable amount of time, you need a project or two. If you're only filling it with refuse from small little projects, you're going to have this thing sitting on your lawn for a loooong time. As it was, we made some built-ins, demo'd a wall in the basement, cleaned out the shop a few times (decimated the scrap lumber pile), built a little kitchen for Tool Snob Jr., and did some other various projects around the house and it took about six months to fill the Bagster up. So, the bottom line is that if Waste Management wanted this review in a timely manner, the gift card is a necessity. It got us going on a few good sized "waste creation' projects, but even then, it's still taken a while to fill the bag. Has it tainted our review? We think not, but that's up to you to decide...

So anyway on to the review...

bagster_full_snow.JPG bagster_handle.JPG

What is a Bagster?
It's a small dumpster made out of a heavy-duty tarp material, like the stuff that they use for those temporary garages that are popular these days. The bag has a handle strap on each side, like a wood carry. Once the bag is filled, just call Waste Management and they'll come and pick it up for a flat fee (to check the price in your area go here, ours would have cost $139). Empty Bagsters are available for about $30, so our total investment would have been around $190. Each Bagster can hold three cubic yards of waste.

Our Experience
We got ours in the middle of the summer and for months we loaded it up and up and up. Then we loaded it some more, and then some more on top of that. Then it snowed about a foot and the next day we called Waste Management to come and pick it up.

bagster_truck.JPG bagster_crane1.JPG
A few thoughts about the Bagster:

1. The Bagster is great in a lot of ways, but we're going to start with the most important one: Mrs. Tool Snob, for some unknown reason, doesn't seem to mind six months of an ever-increasing pile of garbage in her driveway, if (and only if) it is surrounded by a green bag made out of heavy-duty tarp material. Seriously. Under any normal circumstances, Mrs. Tool Snob would have gutted us stem to stern after about three weeks with a debris pile in front of the garage. But because it was semi-contained in a green baggie, it was somehow OK. A full-sized dumpster wouldn't have been OK, and that very same pile, just without the bag, wouldn't have been OK either. Add the green bag...OK.

2. If you're thinking about getting one, make sure to read the FAQ at the Bagster website, particularly the part about where you can and cannot place a Bagster. If your Bagster is inaccessible by the crane truck that comes to pick it up, you're pretty much out of luck. There are overhead clearances to be aware of as well as 'distance from the driveway' measurements.


3. Be smart about stuffing the Bagster. We spent a year as low man on the jobsite totem pole and in that time we were forced to master the fine art of 'dumpster crushing.' Countless times, and in the worst weather imaginable, we'd be sent out to 'get another 10% out of the dumpster.' There's a certain way to fill a dumpster and about 1000 ways not to do it. Because the Bagster is so inexpensive, maximizing the space is particularly satisfying, you'll feel like you're really getting your money's worth.

The Bagster worked out great for us and with another renovation planned in the next couple months and we're considering getting another one. It's a painless process and three cubic yards goes a long way. The driver who did the pick-up (Pete) told us that they're really popular in the suburbs and that roofers like them a lot too because they can get three or four of them and plop them right on the lawn in places where you'd never dare put a roll-off dumpster.


So when it comes down to it, we think that the bagster is great. But we also know that our dump has a pretty good policy on construction debris (a truck-load is $20), so if we're willing to load up our trash and haul it away, a Bagster isn't really worth it. But dump policies differ and some people don't even have access to one, so it's a matter of figuring out if it's something that works for you. It's a great option to have for the city/suburb dweller who might have limited space or a contractor with a small job. It's also nice that you own the bag outright and there's no rental fee, like on a regular dumpster.

UPDATE: Make sure to check out what Paul says in the comments section. He's got another great use for the bagster.

To get all the information you need on the Bagster, go to TheBagster.com.

Bagsters available at Amazon.com

Read More in: All Reviews | Building Materials | Demolition Tools | Lawn/Garden

Share this Article with others: social bookmarking

Related Articles:

Came straight to this page? Visit Tool Snob for all the latest news.

Posted by Doug Mahoney at January 21, 2011 6:00 AM
Recent Comments

I will never use a bagster again. I had a small job just 5 miles north of the Home depot I bought this bagster, and the wouldn't pick it up. Never again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Ken Morff at July 31, 2013 3:25 PM

The review and comments here have made up my mind..... I just bought a house, and i am planning on pulling some cabinets out of the kitchen maybe, and ripping up A LOT of carpet (beautiful hardwood underneath) and i was not sure whether to just fill up a trash can and wait for them to pick it up, or to get a Bagster. It seems like i can get the bagster and continue to throw some stuff in there until it is full! :)

Thank you very much!

Posted by: Ben at June 13, 2012 8:51 AM

Tried to use that Bagsters thing as an alternative to regular bins, but run in to many problems with this ,so called Bagsters.
I filled it a bit lover then top , all according their instruction, but after 2 weeks found that bag was still in the same place – no any attempt to contact me by email or by phone what so ever. Besides I found that my credit card was charged extra 50 $ , so I called Bagster finding out that driver did not want to pick the bag ,as according to him it was overloaded over the top and one side of the bag was too close to the fence ! Great service – so it came total to 210 $ for 3 c.yards of waste and it was not even picked up.
I can see few issues there:
1. Bad communication
2. Your card might be charged without even your permission.
3. Too many limitations how to fill this bag
4. Too expensive for amount of waste you can get read of , if you are lucky of course .

Jan , happy FORMER Bugster customer 

Posted by: Jan at April 19, 2012 11:25 AM

Whether Waste Management will pick up you bag or not is completely dependent on the whim or driving skills of the driver. I was a little dubious when I bought my first bag so I didn't fill it full of heavy stuff just in case. I was around when they came to pick it up so I asked the driver if where I place the bag was ok. He said the spot was no problem. So I placed a second bag in the same spot and filled it up. Now they won't pick it up. The second driver says our driveway is too narrow even though it's 20 feet wide and the same company has delivered full size 15 yard dumpsters in the past. So it's just dependent on the driver and whether he can be bothered.
The customer service line was unable to provide an address to which I could send a complaint

Posted by: Neil at August 4, 2011 1:26 PM

I've used a Bagster too and had a really good experience. We filled it with the demo from a half bath and could have easily added more. It's very convenient but double check the website as they don't pickup in all areas.

Posted by: ethan@OPC at January 21, 2011 9:11 AM

Great point....$30 for SuperTarp. Think I might follow your lead and get one just for yard debris...

Posted by: Tool Snob at January 21, 2011 9:03 AM

the bagster is also super useful for yard waste. my yard is big enough that i'd go broke buying enough yard waste bags to clean it all but not big enough to warrant calling a professional. The bagster fits great in the back of a tacoma. Plop that bad boy in the back of your truck, fill it up with your various dead tree parts and find yourself a place to dump it. drag the bagster half out of the truck, then back the truck up and it will topple over, hopefully landing upside down. presto - all your leaves gone, your truck is clean, and you have a kick ass reusable bag.

Posted by: paul at January 21, 2011 8:37 AM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Please enter the letter "m" in the field below:
Please press Post only once. Submission of comments takes up to 20 seconds because of Spam Filtering.

Join the Mailing List Newsletter
Enter your Email

Powered by FeedBlitz
Subscribe - RSS

facebook_badge.jpg twitter_badge.jpg

Recent Reviews
Recent Comments
james sanders: Borrowed Wagner paint eater from brother in law, working good read more
Bryan: Can you get the older molded stud 4 sure I read more
kevin kirkpatrick: I had a green Poulan for 20 years and it read more
Gary Schultz: Thinking about the red wing 2218. Will be doing a read more
Walt: How much does the 80 Volt Kobalt weigh? read more
Site Navigation

Visit our other properties at Blogpire.com!


This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
All items Copyright © 1999-2017 Blogpire Productions. Please read our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy